Welcome to Mafia Pizza / now known as Papa & Nonna’s Pizzeria
Mafia Pizza, now known as Papa & Nonna’s Pizzeria, is a gem located at 850 N Jefferson St in Monticello, FL. The restaurant is renowned for its inviting atmosphere and quick, friendly service, ensuring diners always feel welcomed. Guests rave about the fresh, delicious food, especially the generously-sized portions and diverse salad bar. Fan favorites include the gluten-free Bianco and delectable calzones stuffed with savory ingredients. Patrons often travel from afar just to indulge in the mouthwatering pizza and chicken wings. With each visit, guests feel like part of the family, thanks to the exceptional hospitality and commitment to quality.
Mafia Pizza / now known as Papa & Nonna’s Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
The atmosphere and service are always top-notch, quick, and friendly. The food is delicious, and nice size portions are made fresh. The salad bar is a favorite with a nice variety of items to build to your own taste and nice selection of dressings to top it with.
Hadn't been back for a long while, tried again and the gluten free Bianco was pretty good tonight. Will go back for that.
Calzones are delicious. I had mine stuffed with pepperoni, sausage and bacon. The Mrs. had sausage; while the youngin had cheese pizza.
I go there once maybe twice a week and the foods great and the service is magnificent
Hands down the best pizza, chicken wings and people! We drive from Valdosta just to get their food and the hospitality is amazing they make you feel like family thank you for doing what you do!!
Delicious! Great service. Nice size restaurant. Pizza, calzone, spaghetti and salad bar- all tasty!
Mafia is a great blend of small town feel and big city flavor! They have good pizza and pretty good wings. Big fan of their Buffalo chicken pizza and the godfather! I don’t think you’ll be disappointed with anything you get at Mafia!
This was the best pizza I've had and there isn't a close 2nd. I tried it today for the 1st time and it was amazing. The husband and wife owners are super friendly and down to earth. I'll be a frequent visitor
Location
-
850 N Jefferson St Unit 810, Monticello, FL 32344, United States Hotline: +1 850-997-4000
Welcome to **Papa & Nonna’s Pizzeria**, formerly known as **Mafia Pizza**, where the essence of family dining meets authentic Italian flavors! Nestled at 850 N Jefferson St Unit 810 in Monticello, FL, this establishment captures the spirit of a warm, friendly neighborhood restaurant, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
One can't help but notice the charming atmosphere as you step inside. Customers rave about the quick and attentive service, where staff greet you with smiles, creating a welcoming environment. As noted by Tammy Lynn Bunting, the ambiance is always top-notch, setting the perfect backdrop for enjoying freshly made dishes.
The menu here strikes a delightful balance between beloved classics and unique creations. Signature highlights include their scrumptious pizzas, customizable calzones, and a well-loved salad bar that offers a variety of fresh ingredients, allowing you to create your own salad masterpiece. Notably, the gluten-free Bianco garners rave reviews, showing the restaurant's commitment to catering to dietary preferences like Rebecca McNairy's recent experience.
For those who crave hearty flavors, their calzones come highly recommended. Mark Shoplak’s enthusiasm for a pepperoni, sausage, and bacon-stuffed calzone demonstrates how they elevate this Italian staple to a delightful indulgence. The generous portion sizes ensure you won’t leave hungry—something that loyal customer Margaret Gilley can attest to after her frequent visits.
The star of the show, however, is undoubtedly the pizza. Amy Meyers describes it as hands down the best, with a nod to their chicken wings as well. The flavor profiles here are rich and inviting, crafted from quality ingredients that speak to the passion of their chefs. It’s no wonder patrons travel from afar, feeling the familial warmth embedded in every dish, much like dining at a beloved relative's home.
At Papa & Nonna’s Pizzeria, every meal feels special, a testament to their dedication to both food and hospitality. Whether you're indulging in a classic slice or exploring new favorite dishes, this pizzeria offers a heartfelt dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.